In the spirit of true Vygotsky fashion teachers strive to find that sweet-spot between the impractically difficult and the excessively easy. To find the edge of a students zone of proximal development and press it gently without pushing them over in to the frustrations of insurmountable failure.
This is the essence of O2. – Offer appropriate challenge in the content area. Teacher candidates plan and/or adapt curricula that are standards driven so students develop understanding and problem-solving expertise in the content area(s) using reading, written and oral communication, and technology.
As a teacher, O2 means to me that I need to find the most challenging exercises for students and scaffold them just enough for them to succeed through their own efforts. This is like helping a child do pull-ups for the first time by gently lifting them as they pull. As the child strengthens the supportive hands fall away.
In our coursework for EDRD 6530, and in my classroom, I have been putting this principle into practice. Below is the body of another blog post about designing a writing workshop to scaffold students towards a district assessment. In this post I use learning from the EDRD 6530 course and apply it to my practical experience.
[It is especially appropriate that the example of a writing workshop in the text (Daniels, Zemelman, & Steineke, 2007) is taken from a history class. Our district assessments are both essays and the way we scaffold for them is with a few kinds of writing workshops. I would say that not only do writing workshops work well for the discipline of social studies, but that they are essential for teaching the complex and discipline specific writing skills expected in social studies.
Our workshops start with the prompt, typically a comparison between civilizations, and a highly structured thought-organizer worksheet. My class is a 9th grade class and they are just starting out with these writing skills so the scaffolding is pretty structured. Each students has a outline to fill in. They must first present evidence on a supplied topic, such as “political control,” for example. Following their evidence, they write a few conclusions using analysis. Once they have done this for several categories they try to find a thread that is common to all their conclusions, and base their thesis off of a combination of the way their evidence seems to be pointing and the prompt.
We try to limit the scope of these workshops by chunking the tasks and providing a narrow prompt. For example, in one lesson we may focus only on careful organization of evidence, saving our conclusions for the next class. The essay assessments are always treated like a test and are given a full 50 minutes for completion.
This kind of workshop relies heavily on the students’ previous investment in the content classes, as it relies on previous learning and research. As such the outcome reflects their participation in the course in general more so than their participation in the actual workshop. This is great for a district assessment, but leaves me wondering if there is a better way to use a writing workshop for actual instruction.]
In this post above you will see that I have learned through study and practice that students require several scaffolds to prepare for a challenging writing assessment. These preparation scaffolds are, a structured organizational exercise, a structured format or syntax, and a well-crafted prompt. With these scaffolds a student’s thinking and preparation can be focused. Students are distressed by vague or open ended instructions, especially when it is an important assessment. The most essential element here is focus and structure.
I have learned that staying focused on the goal of the assessment, and providing structure are essential elements to everything in the curriculum. As I design curriculum, or adapt the curriculum I am given, it is essential to continually return to these principles.
With structure, and focus to keep energy flowing productively it is possible to really hit that extreme edge of the ZPD and see students challenge themselves and grow. This doesn’t always happen, in fact not very often for me as a novice teacher. However, when it does, I always learn something that I am able to put into practice later. As such I would confidently say that I am growing into the Hope principle of O2, and will continue to grow in it with every unit I design.