O2 Providing a Challenging Curriculum

In the spirit of true Vygotsky fashion teachers strive to find that sweet-spot between the impractically difficult and the excessively easy. To find the edge of a students zone of proximal development and press it gently without pushing them over in to the frustrations of insurmountable failure.

This is the essence of O2. – Offer appropriate challenge in the content area. Teacher candidates plan and/or adapt curricula that are standards driven so students develop understanding and problem-solving expertise in the content area(s) using reading, written and oral communication, and technology.

As a teacher, O2 means to me that I need to find the most challenging exercises for students and scaffold them just enough for them to succeed through their own efforts. This is like helping a child do pull-ups for the first time by gently lifting them as they pull. As the child strengthens the supportive hands fall away.

In our coursework for EDRD 6530, and in my classroom, I have been putting this principle into practice. Below is the body of another blog post about designing a writing workshop to scaffold students towards a district assessment. In this post I use learning from the EDRD 6530 course and apply it to my practical experience.

[It is especially appropriate that the example of a writing workshop in the text (Daniels, Zemelman, & Steineke, 2007) is taken from a history class. Our district assessments are both essays and the way we scaffold for them is with a few kinds of writing workshops. I would say that not only do writing workshops work well for the discipline of social studies, but that they are essential for teaching the complex and discipline specific writing skills expected in social studies.

Our workshops start with the prompt, typically a comparison between civilizations, and a highly structured thought-organizer worksheet. My class is a 9th grade class and they are just starting out with these writing skills so the scaffolding is pretty structured. Each students has a outline to fill in. They must first present evidence on a supplied topic, such as “political control,” for example. Following their evidence, they write a few conclusions using analysis. Once they have done this for several categories they try to find a thread that is common to all their conclusions, and base their thesis off of a combination of the way their evidence seems to be pointing and the prompt.

We try to limit the scope of these workshops by chunking the tasks and providing a narrow prompt. For example, in one lesson we may focus only on careful organization of evidence, saving our conclusions for the next class. The essay assessments are always treated like a test and are given a full 50 minutes for completion.

This kind of workshop relies heavily on the students’ previous investment in the content classes, as it relies on previous learning and research. As such the outcome reflects their participation in the course in general more so than their participation in the actual workshop. This is great for a district assessment, but leaves me wondering if there is a better way to use a writing workshop for actual instruction.]

In this post above you will see that I have learned through study and practice that students require several scaffolds to prepare for a challenging writing assessment. These preparation scaffolds are, a structured organizational exercise, a structured format or syntax, and a well-crafted prompt. With these scaffolds a student’s thinking and preparation can be focused. Students are distressed by vague or open ended instructions, especially when it is an important assessment. The most essential element here is focus and structure.

I have learned that staying focused on the goal of the assessment, and providing structure are essential elements to everything in the curriculum. As I design curriculum, or adapt the curriculum I am given, it is essential to continually return to these principles.

With structure, and focus to keep energy flowing productively it is possible to really hit that extreme edge of the ZPD and see students challenge themselves and grow. This doesn’t always happen, in fact not very often for me as a novice teacher. However, when it does, I always learn something that I am able to put into practice later. As such I would confidently say that I am growing into the Hope principle of O2, and will continue to grow in it with every unit I design.

Posted in O2, reflections | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Textbook Fail & Finesse

Attached below is a PowerPoint presentation detailing a time when the textbook by itself was not sufficient. I was able to fix this in a future lesson and then avoid the failure entirely the following semester. See below…

Textbook Fail & Finesse

Posted in EDRD 6530, reflections | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Bloggery 5: Writing Workshops

It is especially appropriate that the example of a writing workshop in the text (Daniels, Zemelman, & Steineke, 2007) is taken from a history class. Our district assessments are both essays and the way we scaffold for them is with a few kinds of writing workshops. I would say that not only do writing workshops work well for the discipline of social studies, but that they are essential for teaching the complex and discipline specific writing skills expected in social studies.

Our workshops start with the prompt, typically a comparison between civilizations, and a highly structured thought-organizer work sheet. My class is a 9th grade class and they are just starting out with these writing skills so the scaffolding is pretty structured. Each students has a outline to fill in. They must first present evidence on a supplied topic, such as “political control,” for example. Following their evidence, they write a few conclusions using analysis. Once they have done this for several categories they try to find a thread that is common to all their conclusions, and base their thesis off of a combination of the way their evidence seems to be pointing and the prompt.

We try to limit the scope of these workshops by chunking the tasks and providing a narrow prompt. For example, in one lesson we may focus only on careful organization of evidence, saving our conclusions for the next class. The essay assessments are always treated like a test and are given a full 50 minutes for completion.

This kind of workshop relies heavily on the students’ previous investment in the content classes, as it relies on previous learning and research. As such the outcome reflects their participation in the course in general more so than their participation in the actual workshop. This is great for a district assessment, but leaves me wondering if there is a better way to use a writing workshop for actual instruction.

Posted in Bloggery, EDRD 6530 | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

P2 Differentiation for Language Acquisition

Differentiation can mean a great many things, and can become an overwhelming concept to a novice teacher. Initially the more I learned about differentiation, the more I imagined unique materials and assignments for every student. The truth is that versatility is better than customization in this context. It is better to have one assignment or activity which can be done in a variety of ways with a variety of helps, than several assignments or activities.

P2 – Practice differentiated instruction. Teacher candidates apply principles of differentiated instruction, including theories of language acquisition, stages of language, and academic language development, in the integration of subject matter across the content areas of reading, mathematical, scientific, and aesthetic reasoning.

P2 means to me including a Swiss army knife set of helps into any reading activity, or activity concerned with academic language. Understanding the challenges that face students as they acquire language, especially students with difficulty acquiring language, is essential in preparing a dynamic and versatile piece of instructional material. A teacher must be aware of the needs of each individual student and find ways to meet those needs in a way that is beneficial to all. In some cases you really do need special materials for only a few students, but most of the time I have found that the helps required by a few students are beneficial to all.

To acquire language students need to read in order to see words used in context. Students need to write in order to cement the words and their appropriate use in their minds. Students also need to use the academic language verbally to associate the sound of the word with its meaning, and practice correct usage. To accomplish this you don’t need several tasks and you don’t need several materials. All a teacher must do is create a flexible material and use it in a variety of ways.

The evidence below is one of several readings I use in class to have the students create a comparison of leadership values and actions between a few famous emperors.

TEXT Octavian reading

You will see that this is only a one page reading. But it is flexible and with correct teaching methods allows for language practice for a diverse class. I use a vocabulary box embedded into the text to help students with either difficult language or language that means something different in this context. For example Augustus has become emperor of the Roman empire and at this time the Roman republic does not exist. However, for propagandist reasons, Augustus still refers to the empire as the republic. I do not often edit readings or primary sources to simplify language. I prefer to leave the complex language in the text and provide a help, such as a vocabulary box, for allow for better access. This allows students to access the material easily, but leaves challenging words for more advanced learners.

Though it is not shown on the sheet, I often instruct students to follow the example of the vocabulary box with annotations. I encourage them to underline difficult or confusing words in the text, and create a vocabulary box of their own either in a margin or on the back side of the page. This is especially helpful for ELL students. Rather than just skipping over hard words and hoping to understand the context, recording these words and resolving them on the back allows to a growing bank of vocabulary words as the class progresses.

With this single reading I can challenge advanced students with new and complex language or contextual language use. I can help ELLs grow a bank of vocabulary that is easy to find and review. I can help my struggling readers by scaffolding difficult language. Finally I can have the whole class, with diverse needs, discussing and working with the same reading-level of text.

I use this and two other readings, one on Wu-di, the other on Chandragupta. Students follow the reading by writing and comparing leadership values and actions. In the course of this exercise they also discuss these factors. This allows for a rich use of academic language involving reading writing and discourse for maximum absorption of the language.

Posted in P2, reflections | Leave a comment

Bloggery 3: A Writing Crisis?

I am cautious about jumping on the bandwagon of doom-criers lamenting the death of writing in this digital age. I do think that the ease and speed with which we use written communication has produced a functional writing style that should barely be considered language. However, eloquence in oration and in writing are still taught and required in schools. I do respect the fact that the craft which was shown in old letters written by hand is not evident in email, and that our recent president’s speeches do not have the beauty or power of many of the presidents that came before them. I would describe this as a concern more than a crisis.

The solution to this concern is the creation of a context for texting-style communication, and a context for elegant pros. Students should be taught that in their classes they must use complete sentences and write persuasively. I often use Think-Pair-Share (TPS) exercises for students to discuss content we have just gone over. I then have them write a reflection on their conversation in their journals. This seems like a solid use of the Writing Break strategy suggested by Daniels, Zemelman, and Steineke. The exit slip is little different than a journal entry, with the exception that they hand it in as they leave. Either way the students have an opportunity to reflect on their learning in written form.

Posted in Bloggery, EDRD 6530 | Leave a comment

Bloggery 4: Mini lesson

Below you will find a mini lesson with a reading wand writing strategy to help students organize information in a document as they read, and then organize their thoughts into a descriptive paragraph.

The topic is the comparison of the Roman Republic to the at of the United States.

*I have recently updated this lesson plan 5/12/15*

mini lesson Roman Republic

Posted in Bloggery, EDRD 6530 | Leave a comment

Bloggery 2: Strategic Reading

I have two brief observations. First, heading one of chapter six is entitled “Don’t Assign the Whole Textbook.” For the record, in my class I am required to have the kids read the whole text book. From this comes many of the difficulties of maintaining student engagement, and seeing real learning. Second, as far as helping secondary students master effective reading strategies, they already have. They have mastered a strategy so effective at bringing up their grades in this course it is hard to get them to try any others. Since they must read the whole book, and much of their grade relies on a fill in the blank work packet, they have mastered skimming for key words or phrases.

I used to marvel that a student will complete their packet perfectly, and then bomb a test, or give me a blank stare in a latter unit when I check for prior learning. Now I see why. They are “reading,” but they are not reading.

I use a word wall often in class to focus on vocabulary as Daniel’s & Zemelman suggest (2014). We often do group readings in class so students can work through vocabulary together. I think the next step will be to try to have strong students read aloud so others can hear the words used as well.

Posted in Bloggery, EDRD 6530 | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Bloggery 1: Textbooks a curse?

In a word, yes.

In this bloggery I will extend Daniels’ and Zemelman’s arguments to my own experience of teaching. Daniels and Zemelman (2014) identify a laundry list of criticisms of content area textbooks, and even summon up some advantages as well. The advantages are these. Textbooks have information in a dense format that can be paired well to the curriculum or standards of your state or district. At their most ideal, textbooks have just the right amount of information to support each lesson covering the broad content of the course, as mandated by your governing authority.

So my first philosophical criticism is this. If this ideal textbook were to enter the class, then why not just make the class a correspondence course using  text-based assessments? The heart and soul of teaching history is understanding the multiple perspectives offered by various people with various values that guide their thinking. The point of knowing history is to talk about with other people and learn from it together. No matter how well written, as the above authors mention, no textbook can ever be so balanced, so broad, so deep, and still be under a thousand pages with few errors.

I have seen students blasted by textbooks with shotgun-facts. Thousands of little factoids, mostly without context or a larger theme to give them continuity or purpose. Its just a massive game of trivia for trivia’s sake. Daniels and Zemelman suggest that instruction should be centered around carefully selected texts, and supported by a classroom set of textbooks to use as references. This gives the teacher the freedom to find and choose voices from history that best address the central focus, in the most culturally relevant way.

In short, text books have their place; on the shelf. The way we are using them they are sucking our money away, breaking our students’ backs, and filling their heads with a meaningless soup of details that give them little or no sense of the great conversation that is living inside of history.

Subjects Matter, Second Edition: Exceeding Standards Through Powerful Content-Area Reading (Authors: Daniels & Zemelman), 2014 edition.

Posted in Bloggery, EDRD 6530 | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

ISTE 1 Digital Story Telling

I have created a Digital Story Telling project in the form of a short family history documentary. I believe this is well matched to the second point of ISTE Standard 1, “Engage students in exploring real-world issues and solving authentic problems using digital tools and resources.”

In this example of a final assignment for a US History class, I encourage students to use technology to practice historiographical skills, and create a source for future historians, either in academics, or their own family. Detailed genealogical information has proved throughout time to be invaluable to the study of history. This is so true that the Library of Congress has, and continues to, conduct a project to gather the stories and histories of everyday Americans. As StoryCorps continues to collect vast amounts of living history for the the posterity of our culture, so might these students for their families.

Assigning this project to students would invite them to test their skills not only as users of technology for entertainment but as users for the community of learning. I was challenged by the planning, and technical skills required for this project. As students and their teachers become more adept new and higher standards of technical and intellectual excellence can be imposed. This project could be posed in a simple form to middle school students, or in high complexity to Seniors. The applications for this kind of learning project are very many indeed, especially in Social Studies, or literature.

Personally, more than any technical ability, I learned from this project that collecting living history is fun, and meaningful. I had a great time preparing for this project and so did my family. Now I will have something to show future generations of Schuldt children when they ask how our family became Hawaii vacationers.

Now, without further adieu, enjoy my Digital Story.

 

Posted in Digital Story Telling, EDTC 6433, reflections, Standard 1 | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

ISTE 5 If it’s not broke don’t fix it

The question 5 (Q5) for ISTE 5 that I focused on was this, to what extent can I make my own learning as a teacher available to the world? As I develop as a teacher I want to share my learning and resources. I think of this as more than posting content , lesson plans, or blogging strategies. I wonder to what extent I could become a mentor to others?

I ended up landing on a resource that is neither new nor unheard of, but it is a ubiquitous, and well established technology. I respect that this course is partly to expose us to new technology or new uses for technology, but let us not suppose that novelty is an end in itself. We care more about being effective than novel. So the resource I chose was Youtube.

Plain and simple if I want my experience as an educator to be available to people everywhere, for free, it really has to be youtube. What other platform is so ubiquitous, so easy to access, and so imminently referable to in conversation. If I say, “oh you can check this out on my channel,” I don’t even need to explain that I’m talking about youtube. Everyone is so conversant with all things youtube, that it seems novelty here may make for a less effective experience.

I would love to subscribe to a few solid teacher channels where I know I can always get good ideas or advice. Why can’t that be me in a few years? Or even now?

This is, in its own way, in keeping with Hope principle H4 – Honor family/community involvement in the learning process.
Teacher candidates inform, involve, and collaborate with families/neighborhoods, and communities in each student’s educational process, including using information about student cultural identity, achievement and performance.

Using a platform that is so intuitive and integrated with the lives of students, families, communities, and other educators, seems like honoring the community culture. With regard to integrating teaching into common technologies, Collins and Halverson (2009) make a good point, “How can we make learning technology available to more people? What tools can support people learning on their own? These are questions about improving education outside of schools.”

What if each teacher had a learning channel of their own, or collaborated on a really excellent learning channel? How might this empower students and learners of all ages to learn on their own time? Wouldn’t it be great if parents could learn along side their kids and make homework a shared experience?

So youtube might not be the innovation of the year but the platform doesn’t need to be. Perhaps we can make strides in innovative teaching by using the simple tools we have already.

Allen Collins & Richard Halverson. Rethinking Education in the Age of Technology: The Digital Revolution and Schooling in America. New York: Teachers College Press, 2009.

 

 

Posted in Classroom Technology, EDTC 6433, H4, Standard 5 | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments